Indian
Education has always been a subject so volatile that any minor change in the
system by either the Union Government or the State Government immediately
sparks off debates, protests against HRD Ministers and causes Media Houses to
call a panel of “experts” to analyze the changes and broadcast the analysis in
their primetime slots.
Arjuna
Ramadoss had become a household name for all the wrong reasons and the
subsequent protests against him was the last instance of a Minister facing
public wrath for introducing changes in the system.
Kapil Sibbal
also tried to bring about changes but the changes were vehemently opposed by
Sonia Gandhi and Manmohan Singh for reasons [obviously] related to polls.
Kapil Sibal
then went on to become a household name and garnered a reputation to be known
as the best person [after Digvijay Singh] who could be used to exemplify words
like “ridiculous”, “weird”, “mentally unsound” by speaking on matters relating
to the CWG Scam and the 2G scam, but that’s another story.
Coming back
to education then, what the country has seen for the past 3 or 4 decades has
resulted in Institutions from US/Canada and the UK having scores of Indians on
their alumni lists. Obviously one of the major reasons for so many students to
go and study abroad [some even choosing to take loans to fund the trips] is the
stupid, completely ridiculous, entirely baffling [and probably one of the
biggest poll gimmicks in Indian Political history] The Quota System or the Reservation
System. This system (or law) guarantees that people of “lower” castes and
religions which make up minority of the population get some seats [which are
often as high as 75-80 % of the total seats] reserved exclusively for them
irrespective of their academic performance and/or intelligence being inferior
to others for whom no such reservations is/are available. Scheduled Castes,
Scheduled Tribes, a class known as OBCs [other backward classes], Nomadic
Castes, Nomadic Tribes and minorities based on religion make up the classes
whose people can avail this “reservation” by showing a caste certificate.
Say if the total reservation in a college amounts to say 80% then of the total persons admitted to that institution 80% must be from the reserved class. If a person from General Category gets higher marks than a person from reserved class then that student can only be admitted if his admission will still ensure that 80% of the total students are from reserved class. If his admission will bring the figure down from 80% he or she cannot be admitted.
Say if the total reservation in a college amounts to say 80% then of the total persons admitted to that institution 80% must be from the reserved class. If a person from General Category gets higher marks than a person from reserved class then that student can only be admitted if his admission will still ensure that 80% of the total students are from reserved class. If his admission will bring the figure down from 80% he or she cannot be admitted.
To speak in
simple words, the people of General Category can only bid for 20% of the seats.
Now though
on paper this looks okay the problem starts immediately when we question the
logic behind the reservations. The logic used by the Government was that ALL
PEOPLE FROM CASTES ARE LOOKED DOWN UPON BY THE HIGHER CASTES, ARE MONETARILY
AND ECONOMICALLY WEAK AND THUS CANNOT BE ADEQUATELY REPRESENTED IN
INSTITUTIONS!!! Great isn’t it? I mean it can’t get more bizarre and ridiculous
that this can it? One may as well ask if the Government is still living in the
pre-independence era.
Where
Universities around the world are looking for intelligent and smart people with
that “bright spark” in them [and devise a series of tests to find those bright
sparks], their India counterparts have to first get the absolutely filthy quota
system in place and then [ if reservation permits] find those bright sparks.
What this
results in is smart people being ignored because someone dumber than him is
from backward classes.
Another
gaping loophole is the phrase “economically backward”. This is the 21st
Century. How many people of backward classes does one know are economically weak???
The next Question is, “How many people of higher castes do you know who are
economically weak???”
The answers
are obvious. So Many Higher Caste People are poor and so many backward class
people are rich that the whole point of quota system collapses in a flash.
The people
who really need assistance are never covered in this system.
Why the
Government can’t realize that by simply helping the economically weak by giving
them monetary concessions like free books and free education and giving them a
place to study is enough to get all on a level playing field???
What this
ultimately results in is that quality students are forced to study in
institution of lesser quality and this ultimately affects the quality of students
this country produces. Their “reserved” counterparts get to top institutes but
cannot utilize the resources provided by the institute the way quality students
would have, had they been there.
To produce
top class professionals this country must stop this extreme stupidity in the
admission process.
Another way
to beat this ridiculous quota system is to study abroad. Those who can afford
education abroad enroll in foreign Universities and then on completing their
courses are handed jobs in the same country. This leaves the Government
Ministers to complain about Brain Drain and blame the students for going abroad
and thus leaving professionals of lower quality back home.
One more
problem that lies in the system is the ridiculous way to judge students’ caliber.
Examinations of regional languages often contain stuff which requires mugging
up. In Maharashtra for instance the Marathi Language papers is nothing about
the language but only about mugging up long passages and reproducing them in
the answer sheet. Thus a person who has absolutely no knowledge of the language
ends up passing the exam with flying colors. If this is how the grading is done
then I can get top marks in any language not just Marathi. Why if Welsh were a
subject then I would mug up the stuff and get perfect scores. Unfortunately
this mugging up does not leave till graduation exams and people who mug up
always get better scores. However during practical sessions they are crudely shown
their place.
The State
Boards never encourage any thinking and the sole emphasis lies on memory. What
this does is when the real test of Brain comes in their way they fail miserably
and show their mettle to the whole world.
Students
Boasting about their State Board marks receive a juggernaut when they are
questioned on stuff requiring intelligence and an analytical mind.
We have even
seen instances where some proud folks who fall under the reservation criteria
boast on how they can ignore studies and get less marks and still get in the top
institutes…
This is the
grim reality of Indian Education. And it doesn’t look like its going to change
anytime soon. Students with class and a superb mind are going to have to
struggle to reach the top while the reserved counterparts will have the journey
made very easy for them by the Government. But once intelligence, analytical
mindset and wit come into play everyone will realize who stands where.
[This
article is dedicated to my friend Abhijeet Patil, who inspired me to write this piece. :)]
By,
Rohit
Thatte.
Original
Writing.
All Rights
Reserved.