Tuesday, 15 April 2014

BJP 3.0?



Irrespective of the election outcome the BJP has reached a point where it is now undergoing a major inflection point a major turning point in the (comparatively) short history of the party.




 

As their Prime Ministerial Candidate criss-crosses the country daily on his Bharat Vijay Rallies in the last leg of campaigning for the Lok Sabha polls for his Bharatiya Janata Party more than his own stature as a PM Candidate it is the fact that he has transformed the party is what catches the eye immediately. That this is the third transformation of the party in a short period of 30 years is what is really the unique story of the party since its relatively recent birth in 1980 in Bombay.
Formed primarily out of the Janata Party experiment and the remnants of the Jan Sangh, the party first rose to power and prominence on the basis of the hard-core Hindutva agenda. This was the first iteration of the BJP was ably and enthusiastically supported by the RSS. The party rose to prominence on the Ram Janmabhoomi issue as well as on other agendas like banning of cow slaughter which was primarily linked to Hindutva. Their official colour is saffron and the lotus is its political symbol.
While both moments (the other being the actual demolition of the mosque) got great traction for the party in the 1990s it was mellowing relatively fast. The BJP did reach highs in electoral politics during those years. A BJP State Govt in UP, winning almost 57 seats in the Lok Sabha polls in UP out of a total of 85 (Uttarakhand was born later) were the highlights. Just as the moment was going past its peak in 1996-1998 there emerged Atal Behari Vajpayee, who (much to the RSS’s annoyance) gave the BJP its second iteration.
From a party that was hard on Hindutva, Vajpayee dropped the contentious issues or led them to a deep backburner. This led to a Vajpayee era in the BJP with Vajpayee becoming its much appreciated and moderate face that pleased the length and breadth of the country.
In the following elections (or rather after three elections) Vajpayee attracted all sorts of allies to the NDA and formed a 24 party coalition Government at the centre that lasted it full term of more than five years (the extra year was added due to the three elections in a short time)
Vajpayee focussed on actively tackling issues and development and laid what is still considered by many as a foundation for India’s good growth in the 2000s. It is even said that while Vajpayee suffered a shock defeat in 2004, the benefits of his schemes trickled down for three-four more years and helped the Congress win a second term in 2009 as they effectively managed to take credit for it by marketing it as “Bharat Nirmaan” etc. Congress reaped what the NDA sowed.
While it is true that the 50% of the roads built in the last 32 years were built by Vajpayee’s Government the same cannot be said about continuation of that and his other development schemes and plans once Vajpayee went out of power. No wonder then that a lack of following of the long term roadmap of medium term development in the years of 2009-10 till today has resulted in dismal growth statistics for the country. However, I digress.
With Vajpayee’s health worsening by the year (he is out of active politics since 2009 and his “latest” available photograph is from three years ago) the Vajpayee era came to an end of sorts in 2009.
The Second iteration of the BJP had brought it great rewards. The BJP came to power in several states and completed successful terms. The BJP from its astonishing 4 LS Seat toehold in Tamil Nadu in 1998 rose to govern the state of Karnataka and complete its state assembly term there too. While 1998’s 4 LS Seats was a huge surprise for the party itself the toehold it gained and Vajpayee’s stature ensured that the people actually started considering the BJP as an option in South India Politics.
A vote to the BJP was once considered as a wasted vote in the Dravidian Party backyards was actually being considered by many there. This was a marked achievement meaning that the BJP had spread its wings in the south too. This Vajpayee era also spawned a string of new BJP leaders who valued development much higher than the conventional Hindutva ideology. Shivraj Chouhan, Manohar Parrikar, Raman Singh are a few notable examples. That they have managed to keep the people in the respective states is also a great achievements.
However despite the change there was always the Hindutva subtext looming large when Advani was the Campaign leader for the 2009 Lok Sabha polls. The new iteration of the BJP was slowly fading away and the need for reinvention was the writing on the wall. Vajpayee was more of an exception to the BJP than the rule. He bucked the trend for the most part than setting it.
Also in the 2000s there came another big turning point in Indian History. AS Indians’ development broadened the issues changed too. Ram Janmabhoomi was a major issue in the 1990s but it slowly faded into oblivion as a new young India emerged with problems and issues like development, power, water, roads, employment, education and free speech taking centre stage. This doesn’t mean that the Hindutva issue is totally absent. Sections of the people do vote for the BJP today because of that only.
This led to the need for another different iteration of the BJP to emerge.
This is precisely what brought Modi into the picture. After Modi won a polarised election in 2002 because of the riots he realized that it would be unwise for the state to be divided and hence he chose the path of development (whether this happened because of choice or lack of it is in debate). His constant focus of development ensured victories in 2007 and 2012. Also the fact that Gujarat which was once a power deprived state today has surplus power is actually one of the facts that helped Modi come to power. Ensuring electricity to more than 95% of his large state is no mean feat in a country where power is not even available in 50% of villages in several large states.
Today with Modi’s entry a BJP that was demoralized in 2009 is coming back in full force once again with a large number of differences that only Modi could have implemented. Firstly is the shunting of the old guard. The old guard represents Hindutva and the old ideology that not many people of this country care for.
Second is the unification of the factions within the BJP to sing in the same tune irrespective of their personal preferences. This was very difficult to do once Vajpayee exited. However it has got more to do with the fact of Modi’s win ability and the fact that Modi can bring the BJP back in power than actual will of the factions inside. However the end result has been what the BJP lacked for seven long years. Unity. The rank and file of the party has been unified in unprecedented measure.
Third is the changing of the agenda. After 2002 it was never going to be easy to rid the 2002 incident that occurred. However twelve years on the solid plank of good governance and development the riots of 2002 seem to have been put aside. Also Rahul Gandhi messing up on the 1984 riots during a TV interview meant that the mileage to be extracted from 2002 decreased drastically.
Fourth is striking a balance to please the RSS and keeping the BJP separate from it. Remember RSS’s ground networks are hugely beneficial for the BJP in any election.
The Poll Rallies and public meetings are always fought on the plank of development and good governance but pleasing the RSS which is still like a parent body (although a long separated parent body) is still an agenda which Modi had to perform otherwise he might not have been anointed as the BJP’s PM Candidate. Modi did it with aplomb and style. Massive Rallies included the points of Development: water, power, roads, education, women safety which Modi hopes to implement along with other growth revival strategies. The Poll Manifesto however included RSS’s strong wishes of the Ram Temple, banning of Cow slaughter etc. Modi managed to keep development central to the manifesto but also kept the Mandir in. OF course Modi and everyone else know that the SC verdict is not going to ensure a Mandir soon but it was crucial enough for the RSS to be put in the manifesto. See how Modi has managed to change the BJP Manifesto. In 1990s the Mandir featured on Page 1 of the manifesto, today it has been moved to page 41. The change is evident. The thin line has been delicately toed by Modi. The people and the organization are both pleased now. The polls already underway predict a large gain for the BJP Vote share. How this translates into votes is anyone’s guess (and a psephologist’s nightmare).
Whatever the result the new BJP is evident. The party has undergone another change. Whether one man caused it or the nations needs caused it is again up for debate but one thing is clear: With the Vajpayee era over and the nation changing drastically it is Narendra Modi whose charisma has led the BJP to yet another new form with a newer ideology and has made the party way more popular to the people of this country than it ever was since its birth in 1980.

Rohit Thatte.
All Rights Reserved.

Sunday, 6 April 2014

Of Crony Capitalism and good work done



Of “Crony” Capitalism....



This election is very different on many counts. The conventional wisdom seems to be thrown out of the window. There is nothing to suggest that the old tricks in the book might work.

Since a few days the Congress has been throwing a new “poll attack” on the BJP PM Candidate Narendra Modi. This new attack has been adopted after the old one of “communalism” failed some might say.
The new charge is of crony capitalism against Narendra Modi in Gujarat for facilitating Adani, Ambani and Ratan Tata’s huge rise in the state that benefitted the corporates much more than the people.  Another charge is that Modi favours the corporates a lot more than state enterprises.
Is this really true? And what does Common sense tell us about this approach? Read on.
First a small note. After 2002 there wasn’t much interest in Gujarat and the companies that did line up at Gujarat’s doors did get in and expanded and hence we see these two corporates associated with the state and Modi.
Secondly Ratan Tata did come in after Modi’s Text message to him in 2009 after the West Bengal drama.

Now for what people want from a Government. All these corporates might have managed large profits but they have given people jobs to the region and from other regions. Voters rate jobs and employment as pretty high this election. So as long as a good clean job is provided they will lap it up and accept it. Consider the alternative. A Government job. Now there is not much a government can do today without the help of a private player or a PSU to create the amount of jobs that are required to satiate the large number of job seekers. The instance of a Government creating huge jobs for all the range of qualified people is rare today if not totally non existent. Secondly Modi has turned around a Gujarat PSU with infusion of professionalism and he was going to need external help to create even more jobs. This help came from the private sector. Also the Central government wasn’t that attractive at offering jobs or rather it didn’t create any.

Secondly let us consider the actual effect a Government undertaken work has. Consider a Government undertaking a huge project and disbursing large amounts of money. This is not going to work that well. History indicates that corruption will rear its ugly head and the government ineptness at meeting deadlines will ensure that the project is a disaster. Enter Modi. He might give the contracts to corporates sometimes even at slightly higher rates but the job will be done impeccably.
Still not convinced? Take a look at Bombay’s dismal roads. They are in pathetic condition every monsoon, however the really good roads can be found at landmarks like Marine Drive. The State might not care for a potholed alley in Kurla but when it comes to prestigious places like South Bombay they work and ensure the BMC and State give awesome roads. What is the secret behind this? Ensuring that contracts are given out to proper big corporate companies like L&T and HCC etc. So where there is capitalism that benefits we don’t mind but apply the same to the roads of an entire state and everybody will start losing their minds.
This discrepancy might draw reactions of sharp criticism from many but making large profits always casts you as a thief or someone.
However if there are any instances of the crony capitalism then they must be the Aircel-Maxis deal, the 2G Scam. The large payouts made to the suppliers of kits during the CWG Games in 2010 indicate the crony capitalism of the UPA.
Coming back to what the country needs it is generally true that private or corporates usually deliver better quality of the finished products than what government undertakings do. The finished products are what the people are going to use and hence people are happier with better finished products.

So bottom line? What really is crony capitalism?
Crony capitalism is actually money paid for shoddy services.
Large sum of money paid for a CWG Bus Stop which crumbled a month after the games. Crony Capitalism.
Large sum of money paid for a high quality world class highway in Gujarat. Smart awarding of contracts.
Large sums of money changing hands in a shoddy clandestine deal for spectrum. Crony Capitalism.
Large sums of money being paid to ensure irrigation and high quality pipelines to Indian Border. Nice move. Strengthening resources in the border towns.

So what I mean is that not all deals involving corporates are corrupt. Of Course people might have proof of corruption against the aforementioned corporate houses and they are free to approach courts. Rather they should and ensure that the guilty are punished.
However to not appreciate some genuinely good contract awarding by Indian politicians is not good. Give credit where due.
People will always appreciate good work done whether it is by a corporate house or by a Government undertaking.

Rohit Thatte

Of Crony Capitalism and good work done



Of “Crony” Capitalism....



This election is very different on many counts. The conventional wisdom seems to be thrown out of the window. There is nothing to suggest that the old tricks in the book might work.

Since a few days the Congress has been throwing a new “poll attack” on the BJP PM Candidate Narendra Modi. This new attack has been adopted after the old one of “communalism” failed some might say.
The new charge is of crony capitalism against Narendra Modi in Gujarat for facilitating Adani, Ambani and Ratan Tata’s huge rise in the state that benefitted the corporates much more than the people.  Another charge is that Modi favours the corporates a lot more than state enterprises.
Is this really true? And what does Common sense tell us about this approach? Read on.
First a small note. After 2002 there wasn’t much interest in Gujarat and the companies that did line up at Gujarat’s doors did get in and expanded and hence we see these two corporates associated with the state and Modi.
Secondly Ratan Tata did come in after Modi’s Text message to him in 2009 after the West Bengal drama.

Now for what people want from a Government. All these corporates might have managed large profits but they have given people jobs to the region and from other regions. Voters rate jobs and employment as pretty high this election. So as long as a good clean job is provided they will lap it up and accept it. Consider the alternative. A Government job. Now there is not much a government can do today without the help of a private player or a PSU to create the amount of jobs that are required to satiate the large number of job seekers. The instance of a Government creating huge jobs for all the range of qualified people is rare today if not totally non existent. Secondly Modi has turned around a Gujarat PSU with infusion of professionalism and he was going to need external help to create even more jobs. This help came from the private sector. Also the Central government wasn’t that attractive at offering jobs or rather it didn’t create any.

Secondly let us consider the actual effect a Government undertaken work has. Consider a Government undertaking a huge project and disbursing large amounts of money. This is not going to work that well. History indicates that corruption will rear its ugly head and the government ineptness at meeting deadlines will ensure that the project is a disaster. Enter Modi. He might give the contracts to corporates sometimes even at slightly higher rates but the job will be done impeccably.
Still not convinced? Take a look at Bombay’s dismal roads. They are in pathetic condition every monsoon, however the really good roads can be found at landmarks like Marine Drive. The State might not care for a potholed alley in Kurla but when it comes to prestigious places like South Bombay they work and ensure the BMC and State give awesome roads. What is the secret behind this? Ensuring that contracts are given out to proper big corporate companies like L&T and HCC etc. So where there is capitalism that benefits we don’t mind but apply the same to the roads of an entire state and everybody will start losing their minds.
This discrepancy might draw reactions of sharp criticism from many but making large profits always casts you as a thief or someone.
However if there are any instances of the crony capitalism then they must be the Aircel-Maxis deal, the 2G Scam. The large payouts made to the suppliers of kits during the CWG Games in 2010 indicate the crony capitalism of the UPA.
Coming back to what the country needs it is generally true that private or corporates usually deliver better quality of the finished products than what government undertakings do. The finished products are what the people are going to use and hence people are happier with better finished products.

So bottom line? What really is crony capitalism?
Crony capitalism is actually money paid for shoddy services.
Large sum of money paid for a CWG Bus Stop which crumbled a month after the games. Crony Capitalism.
Large sum of money paid for a high quality world class highway in Gujarat. Smart awarding of contracts.
Large sums of money changing hands in a shoddy clandestine deal for spectrum. Crony Capitalism.
Large sums of money being paid to ensure irrigation and high quality pipelines to Indian Border. Nice move. Strengthening resources in the border towns.

So what I mean is that not all deals involving corporates are corrupt. Of Course people might have proof of corruption against the aforementioned corporate houses and they are free to approach courts. Rather they should and ensure that the guilty are punished.
However to not appreciate some genuinely good contract awarding by Indian politicians is not good. Give credit where due.
People will always appreciate good work done whether it is by a corporate house or by a Government undertaking.

Rohit Thatte