Saturday, 22 March 2014

BITING THE HAND THAT FEEDS?



MUD SLINGING IN POLITICS REACHED A NEW LOW RECENTLY WITH KEJRIWAL CALLING THE ENTIRE MEDIA CORRUPT. THIS ACCUSATION WAS REITERATED BY A JOURNALIST NOW A MEMBER OF THE AAP.


Few people would have adjectives like "underdog" "spectacular" "rising star" describing them, even fewer would have all of them used at once.
Unless of course you are Arvind Kejriwal. Ever since he secured a spectacular 28/70 seats in the Delhi assembly elections held around the new year his rise has been the perfect phenomenon that can be used to describe a new political rise in India's independent history. This phenomenon was unlike others which used to have rallies and pamphlets and chowk sabhas. Kejriwal used two of the newest most potent "weapons" to further his agenda. The Mainstream media and social media.
Although few would disagree that Narendra Modi is the undisputed king of mainstream and of  Social Media communications with 3.5m plus twitter followers and even more Facebook page likes. This achievement assumes even more significance considering that the youth form a large chunk of social media and Modi at 63 is no youngster.
Coming back to Kejriwal, the media attention assured Kejriwal of attention in assembly polls. Anti corruption and leftist populism were his only agendas which worked when the audience was as small as Delhi.

Forward fifty days after 29 Dec. AAP in disarray. Promises starting to fall apart, a racist minister shaming the country in Somnath Bharti, a Dharna which irritated more people than it pleased and chaos everywhere. Finally the CM who appeared very reluctant to assume office resigned over a petty dispute; a bill which opposition was backing to the hilt. However with publicity waning and bad press increasing with the weird antics (the police raid which is now in courts) and more serious charges of violating women rights by arresting women at night the CM had no choice but to resign after a feebly put argument.
All the opposition wanted before passing the Lokpal bill was sacking of a racist minister. However Kejriwal refused to budge and resigned.
This cast doubts over his governance. Within days he was back on the streets with the same antics that had earned him fame and publicity.
However a lot had changed in fifty days.
The very people that formed the backbone of Kejriwal voters immediately became sceptical after a government high on populism and  low on actual governance caused numerous doubts in people's minds. 
Even then with a few more roadshows it became clear he still could just hold on to that support at least till May.
Now, when you do positive stuff which is appreciated by the people the media will report that and laud you but when you do otherwise the same media will report it and criticize.

Politicians and public personalities have learnt to take it in their stride and move on. Public personalities other than Mr. Kejriwal that is.
Mr. Kejriwal couldn't bear a single negative thing about the AAP ever. From criticizing the other political parties to criticizing the media has been a paradigm shift for him. A very costly mistake though.

While everyone blames the media once in a while (and rightly so, film stars do it all the time) they brush off the issue and move on and so does the media.
However go to the deep end and it will sting you. Calling sections of the media corrupt (not necessarily monetarily) might not be that wrong (Film personalities would shiver if they were to read all small magazines on film) but calling the entire media corrupt certainly classifies as a huge mistake. A very costly blunder for a politician.

Looking in to the matter a bit we can actually find out why Mr. Kejriwal is pretty wrong. First he claimed a media blackout of AAP after he criticized Mukesh Ambani.
Now that may seem quite logical in India given the "influence of powerful people" but then if you were to look closely a different picture appears. The eight nine months in question saw the media ignoring not just Kejriwal but also Vijay Goel, Harsh Vardhan, the BJP and also (barring the corruption against Sheila, the congress). The simple reason is that Delhi elections were some time away.  That claim of media ignorance would certainly apply to other politicians too. They aren't crying out loudly.
Secondly he accuses the media of showing him in a bad light.
Again we don't need to go far to debunk that claim. Generally politicians grab people's interests because of governance and performance. Good or bad. You must have some performance. Digvijay Singh would probably take the title of the worst performance as CM if such a pageant were held (political pundits were amazed after the seats BJP won in LS 04 and it was attributed to the fact of the Anti Digvijay wave being so strong that it refused to subside even after state Polls). Modi certainly has World Bank Praises for Gujarat roads, electricity and water in 85%+ villages as his accomplishments. Kejriwal got 49 days to do something. He did a Dharna and refused to sack a Somanath Bharti. What else would media report?  His free water and subsidized power claims caused economic concern of Delhi breaching the Debt ceiling. The debt ceiling news wasn't played much in non-economic media. So moral of the story: your achievements (or the lack of it) decide your publicity. Moreover if there is anyone who has been shown in the worst possible light in the last twelve years its (ironically) Kejriwal's Archrival Narendra Modi. And given the amount of popularity Modi enjoys despite the Media Trials and mud being thrown at him its quite clear that when media shows you in a bad light you ignore them and work and achieve to force them to show you in a proper light.
However calling the entire media paid like Mr. Kejriwal did is gonna stir up a hornet's nest. No wonder that AAP Debate Panelists got torn apart on various television news debates by the anchors (BJP leaders just smiled and let the anchors talk)

The third thing is actually quite ironic too. Kejriwal doesn't have a policy strategy. All he talks of is anti corruption and that's it. What does keep him in the media is that he throws mud at everyone. When so much mud flies around you got to report that person on TV. Kejriwal was bereft of a policy agenda so he spent all his time throwing mud at everyone. Ambani, Congress, Rahul, Sonia etc etc. That worked for state polls. Now if the aforementioned didn't complain against Kejriwal then I see no reason for the reverse to not be true. If you throw mud others will too. Or if you are Rajnath Singh you come up with a witty slogan like "Jitna jyada keechad fekoge utne jyada Kamal khilenge"
However here is why this could be dangerous for Kejriwal to continue down this road.
One. Kejriwal was supported by people who got to know him from the media. In Bombay nobody would have heard of him if not for social media some mainstream media articles.
Two. These people who form the chunk of his support aren't fools. You give them anti corruption as an agenda. They vehemently agree.
You give them no national policy agenda. They frown.
You give them publicity stunts and tantrums. They say you are just another politician and vehemently disagree and move on.

Three: His support base is mostly the youth. The fast-lane youth.
Firstly if a sixty three year old man is captivating the youth ( and a forty three year old is shunned) and has millions following him on Twitter, a few tantrums and publicity stunts are not gonna get Mr. Kejriwal votes or attention. We need performance, confidence, strength of mind. Melodrama is not going to work.

Four. The person he wishes to challenge isn't incumbency weakened and corruption ridden like Sheila Dikshit. Narendra Modi is a clean, well established Three time Chief Minister with an impeccable track record. His agenda is well spelt out.
 While throwing mud drowned Sheila Dikshit, the same strategy isn't going to work on Modi at all. In fact it would spur reactions of anger towards Kejriwal more than towards Modi. Modi supporters know Modi's agenda of development, agriculture, safety, security, foreign policy well. The media has put it out and given it its due. Modi's cards are on the table. Kejriwal on the other hand has not got any cards and is trying to do something about it. He blames the media for being on Modi's payrolls. Here again the well educated media savvy youngsters who know AAP see through this trick and drift away from AAP.

Five. When it is the media that got you into prominence you can't blame the media as being paid if someone else hogs your limelight.

Six: society knows most of the media's faults. Sensationalism and drama is old news. People see through in a trice. Alarmingly most AAP Supporters already know this and can decipher the truth from the sensationalism veil.
Calling the entire media corrupt is a big lie. The truth is out there for all to see. This from Kejriwal leeks of hypocrisy.
So where does this leave Mr. Kejriwal?
Media bashing has been a quick way to quieten the issue for a lot many public figures. However going off to the deep end isn't going to always yield results or let the issue die. While Kejriwal might have helped the BJP by this, one must remember the intricacies of Indian Politics. The hardcore AAP supporters will see this as a minor blip and return to vote for them. However they might have ruined their chances especially of their candidates getting defeated (wherever they will be defeated) gracefully. This tantrum from the AAP head has caused the Uncertain voters to go away from the AAP towards the BJP.
Kejriwal might have set a new level of political mud slinging but given the fact that voters in India are ridiculously hard to predict especially with a phenomenon like the AAP,  the " all media is corrupt" strategy might not damage him as much as some feel as Elections are still twenty days away- unless he rakes it up again and again before April 10.

Rohit Thatte.
Original Writing.
All Rights Reserved.