Monday, 19 March 2012

WHERE HAS THE GOOD OLD PAV BHAJI GONE?



A stall, a cart, a corner or sometimes just a chair in a shade somewhere is what provides what is needed to sufficiently satisfy a Mumbaikar’s abdomen. Mumbai is famous for its trademark dishes be it the cutting chai or the Vada Pav or the Pav Bhaji or the spicy Misal Pav.
For a Mumbaikar, it is not needed to point out that these delicacies are a part of their lives; it is assumed and so incorporated in their lives that we do not need to point it out.
The Pav Bhaji is one such delicacy which has served Mumbai faithfully but as I now realize until the turn of the century only.
Since 2000s there has been a slight but distinct change in the Bombay Pav Bhaji something which was noticeable but was ignored my many mostly owing to the fact that they were either too busy [it’s a good mid work snack] or thought it as a one off incident. Obviously gluttons who gourmandize on this delicacy would hardly notice as long as two extra greasy pavs with another plate of Bhaji are coming their way. But the fact is that it has changed. And unfortunately it has gone downhill instead uphill.
Many would remember the Pav Bhaji of the late 90s and early 2000s as something of a perfect blend of mashed potatoes and tomatoes,  garlic , a few greenies like peas and bell peppers some other veggies and coriander all mixed in that slurpy masala. And yes of course Pavs, slightly reddish, mirroring the color of the Bhaji with chopped onion and a lemon quarter thrown in to complete the space on the plate. The flavor of this dish available then was distinct, had a taste which would leave the Bhaji melt with the pavs and the flavours would touch all corners of your mouth in an extremely satisfying way. One would just love the taste immeasurably…
BUT
When a person eats the delicacy now it is just tastes like reddened mashed potatoes treated [note the word treated is meant to be used in the same sense like treating a handkerchief with starch or like chemical treatment] with a lot of garlic and the masala has begun to taste weirder by the day.
So, what has changed?
This dish was invented as a healthy and nutritious alternative to a full-fledged meal by-it is believed- vendors in or near Bombay’s famous Textile Mills which are now redundant. AS a heavy meal wouldn’t help the labourers, a normal Rice/roti was replaced by pavs and the curries were coalesced into one thick mixture, the Bhaji. This then found its way into restaurants and became a famous delicacy.
Initially, the places which used to sell the dish were usually corners of Bombay’s streets located near industries. With mills closing and many industries leaving Bombay for the far flung suburbs, the Restaurants and Hotels of the city remain the only places that serve this dish today. Many now wouldn’t even know that the earliest Pav Bhaji outlets were on carts which opened shop as per workers’ shifts. Some were open till 3am while some opened shop at 5am and other such “weird sounding” times.
With time the original composition of the Pav Bhaji found its way into restaurants. These restaurants became places “which also sold Pav Bhaji” till the mills’ exit. Now they are the “only places which sell Pav Bhaji”, at least for most of the public. There still are carts selling Pav Bhaji in South Bombay but these are rare and hard to find and open again as per workers’ convenience.
No then enough of history. Let’s dig deep into the issue. Till 2000 the restaurants and many outlets serving this dish used the good old recipe. But the late 1990s and early 2000s saw a new phenomenon come into picture. This was known as the “maximizing profits” phenomenon. This resulted from economic issues like high cost of raw materials, high labour cost and high rentals creeping into the system which made it highly uneconomical for businesses to run. The only way out of this was compromising on the culinary recipes or raising prices. As raising prices were still looked down upon and provoked anger then, the former alternative was chosen. Substituting the bell peppers and peas were tried but as even substitutes became expensive the greenies were later withdrawn from the recipe. This was the first significant change in the Pav Bhaji. Later as a change of taste was unavoidable the garlic quotient was increased in an effort to mask the absence. This made our mouths water but spoiled the originality of the dish. Then came the era of the colors as it is called. In the early 2000s many cases regarding use of artificial colors in the Bhaji and other foods surfaced. Though not entirely incorrect, this practice, sometimes led to unsafe colors being added. This eased up the tomatoes’ role of the coloring. Thus in order to maximize revenues and increase profits the restaurants spoiled the dish. But they cannot be blamed in entirety as after all it would be very difficult for a non profitable business to continue.
Later in the late 2000s as profitability and revenue making assumed manic proportions the expensive ingredients were further replaced and what we now have on our hands is the cheap but economically feasible version of the great dish. It has artificial taste put on by flavours to replicate a delight of a dish. The quantities have reduced by leaps and bounds so that we must ask for the overpriced extra pavs and extra Bhaji.
As people have no alternative but to consume this scaled down version of the dish nobody complains much as it would be ineffective as changing the dish isn’t possible now.
Another reason for the pav bhaji’s declining taste is the money it generates. It is quick to make so customers don’t have to wait. It is tasty. And customers will always prefer paying the extra money for a quick bite, rather than wait for a while. And when time is concerned a little compromise on money and taste is always overlooked.
Alas, the revenue making, business-like approach will never cease and will result in ruining of dishes.
Having said that the good old Pav Bhaji is still sold in some restaurants across the city however they are few in number and are hardly known much. The famous ones continue to rake in the moolah while we are left to embark on a quest to find these places which still sell the real stuff and continue to thrive hoping we will someday find them. The carts and outlets still await us…
Having said this much about the Pav Bhaji, I must put in a thought for the other delicacies like the Misal, Pohè and the Vada pavs which have thankfully been spared such a fate as reduction in quantities has always worked and also these are generally available for less than Rs.15 [¢30] so revenue generation was never really possible with these. But the Pav Bhaji which usually sells for around Rs.50 to Rs.70 [$1 to $1.2] it provides the perfect avenue for money generation.
Who would have thought that we would have to roam and embark on a quest to find the genuine version of our own native dish…? But that’s how it is folks; coz in 2012 money will always be in the picture…
It is for those of who you continue to seek that golden Pav Bhaji of Bombay that I have written this article. I found it pretty sad that one of Bombay’s dishes has deteriorated with hardly anyone noticing or ignoring it if they have noticed. The taste buds must be given consideration and genuine must remain genuine… Maybe home is the only place you’ll get the genuine recipe now so go ahead, get the veggies and make a memorable Pav Bhaji and yes the original one...

By,
Rohit Thatte,
Original Writing,
All Rights Reserved.