Tuesday, 31 December 2013

2014: OF LIP SERVICE AND IMPLEMENTATION



ENOUGH HAS BEEN SAID AND PROMISES HAVE BEEN MADE FOR DECADES BUT IF 2013 WAS ANYTHING TO GO BY, THERE WAS ONE SMALL GLIMMER OF HOPE THAT WHAT WAS PROMISED WOULD ALSO START BEING IMPLEMENTED WHICH MIGHT BROADEN AND SHAPE 2014. HERE IS TO HOPING THAT IT DOES.



IF YOU WERE TO PICK ONE IRRITATING THING THAT INDIANS ARE VERY GOOD AT THEN THAT would definitely be lip service and grand talk. Indians are very efficient at assuring others that they will do something pronto only to procrastinate, drag their feet and finally accomplish the promised tasks after several deadlines leaving some very scowling frustrated faces in their wake.
However for the first time in ages 2013 actually saw implementation of promises by some very notable individuals. What makes it even more astonishing and hard to believe is that the implementation or delivery of promises came from two Chief Ministers of Indian States. Yes! Politicians! Hard to believe? Believe it.
Before we proceed I must clarify this (to infuse some belief and sanity into the matter) that the effective implementation came from BJP and not the Congress (there, suddenly you see scope for believing it, don’t you?)
For the first time in independent India two out of the four states which saw incumbents return to the chair saw elections being fought on the basis of effective execution of promises and sharp no nonsense approach of the CMs towards achieving that goal.
Neither am I talking about Narendra Modi (the Gujarat elections were in 2012 in any case) nor am I referring to Delhi.
I talk about Chhattisgarh’s Raman Singh and Madhya Pradesh’s Shivraj Singh Chouhan.
Two astute politicians. Two different politicians. Effective and sharp.
Chhattisgarh’s people were promised rice at highly subsidized rates of Rs.1 per kg. Rather than announcing an exorbitant amount of rice at a price that seemed too good to be true (like the heavily criticized Congress poll promises regarding food which fall flat as they are impractical) Raman Singh chose to abide by sanity. He made sure that the said amount of certain kilograms of rice was delivered to all households bang on time for his tenure. A truly stellar implementation by a CM. Something that has never been done before in India. That was enough to assure him another term as CM as he truly is a people’s CM. His Food Security Act preceded the UPA’s Poll Year Announcement of the Food Security Bill and Raman Singh’s Food Security remains the original correctly executed one.
Madhya Pradesh CM chose humility and simplicity to abide to and he too caught the imagination of his people with his spotlight on development promises and food subsidy promises which were duly delivered with precise execution. He worked more like a common man and with the people. MP Women were making on camera statements calling him a “chacha” (uncle) and a “gharwala” (member of their family).

Both states have their fair share of caste based and religion based politics and Chhattisgarh had the additional sympathy wave on which the opposition was riding. However the results proved that the new Indian cares more about actual delivery of promises rather than making new promises and dividing people by caste and religion. This was why after a rise in turnout both states saw incumbents return to power.
Arvind Kejriwal only came along later in Delhi. This happened before, not just for some time but for five years before Kejriwal.
This is what we must take forward in 2014. Implementation. Execution. Deliveries.
If India is to rise as a nation and reach newer strengths this is what we need. The writing on the wall is as clear as it has been in recent times. India wants existing promises delivered and not new populist votebank policies like the Food Security Bill.
This is why what started as a small exception in 2013 needs to be continued and made into a rule.
Politics is only one area where efficient execution is required but it had to be highlighted here as it was the unlikeliest of all to start this trend on such a scale. Even in Public service we need effective execution. Most importantly we need to effectively, efficiently and quickly reduce corruption. That is not the only one.
The condition of Bombay’s roads cannot be improved by announcing contracts worth millions of rupees. It needs one decisive decision and contract awarding. If Marine Drive is rarely in bad condition then why can’t we have the same for the other roads? The question is simple and for a change the answer simpler.
All walks of life demand effective implementation and decisiveness. Dilly dallying over an issue needs to be a thing of the past.
IF India has to transform that glimmer of hope into bright light cashing in is what is necessary. Fortunately things are looking up. Things are closer now than ever before. Whether we seize this opportunity with both hands and whether we allow it to be an exception of 2013 and continue to fall back in our decades long stupor is what will decide our fate.

Rohit Thatte.
Original.
All Rights Reserved.



The Bigger They Are...


2013 WAS A YEAR THAT SAW WOMEN TRULY RISE AFTER DECADES OF SUPPOSED OPPRESSION, 2013 PICKED UP FROM WHERE WE LEFT IN 2012 AFTER THAT FATEFUL NIGHT OF DEC 16, 2013 SAW SEVERAL BIGWIGS APPARENTLY AT THE TOP OF THEIR RESPECTIVE PROFESSIONAL PEDESTALS SUCCUMB TO THEIR LIBIDOS. Does 2014 ALSO PROMISE MORE OF THE SAME?








Power Corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely. This cliché has been thrown around enough number of times in the past few years (thanks to the UPA’s grand corruption but more on that in another article, not this one). Yet this cliché sums up the events of the year.


After that night in Delhi, a lot has changed. While normally such a brutal gang rape would spark fear and make women avoid the streets alone, the exact opposite happened. Women, the youth and citizens fed up of the agony finally released the shackles and said enough was enough. Protests spilled out on the streets, Sheila Dikhsit and the Centre unleashed lathis, bans on meetings and water cannons on peaceful protestors in Delhi. This violation of constitutional rights only made the people more incensed. The consequences of India’s anger were far reaching. Not only did it cause Parliament to pass laws but also led to women becoming more emboldened in reporting instances of harassment which evidently led to the fall of the high and mighty who till this point were protected by their stature and their powers to intimidate. However not anymore. Political proximity, professional achievements and their power drawing careers which were deterring factors were all thrown out of the window as women rose and raised their voices against harassment and exploitation





It’s often said that for a message to be delivered some big fish needs to be brought to justice.


2013 did just that.


A self-styled Godman who had declared himself “Godly” in 2001 was finally brought to book. From his lavish ashrams wherein he raped adolescent girls he now resides in a place where all the women are very happy to see him in: a Jodhpur Jail. A girl who was raped finally decided to stand up and lodged a police complaint. This changed it all. Despite threats to the girl’s family she stood firm and continued her fight. Asaram tried all tricks in the book from calling it a political conspiracy to hailing the opposition party’s win in Rajasthan but to no avail. Asaram’s “miracles” finally finally ran out and in he went. Heck such was the anger that even Maoists decided to issue threats to his ashrams. People (and this included many of his devout followers) who believed that it was indeed a conspiracy had no moral high ground left to go to when Asaram’s son chose to run and hide; a sign in crime circles which is indicative that the accused is indeed guilty.





The next incident occurred in Bombay. A young photojournalist who was raped stirred up the issue again and led to even more anger. Questions were raised whether Bombay was safe for women and this really raised the anger pitch. People simply couldn’t take it anymore.





A few months later another powerful bigwig bit the dust, this time in Goa. The editor in chief of Tehelka Magazine which specialized in sting operations and exposing corruption especially that related to big names in the country was left with nowhere to hide after he raped a woman in a lift at a meet in Goa. Tarun Tejpal also tried his dirty tricks including calling it a political conspiracy, sending people to threaten the woman’s family in Bombay and also (shockingly) asking his junior Shoma (yes a woman) to cover it up. Both had to resign and Tejpal is now in Jail.





However as far as big names and dirt is concerned an ever bigger lump of dirt sprang up hitting the pinnacle of the Judiciary, the Supreme Court. An SC Judge who has given several crucial verdicts in his career was accused of harassment by his intern who revealed all in a blog post. Such is the stature of the culprit that the woman was even reluctant to approach the police as the man in question was a judge. Justice AK Ganguly now finds himself nowhere to hide. He too tried his bag of tricks asking why the affidavit filed by the woman was revealed to the press. In fact because he was an SC Judge the matter dragged on with both the central and state government dragging their feet before finally submitting a cabinet note promising and initiating action.





Such has been the ride for justice in 2013. India has had a history of being patriarchal but the way women were treated by some thugs and criminals and also looked down upon by some for decades had to have an opening to release its pent up anger. Something had to give and it did.


They say that revolutions are what change the face of a nation and what started twelve and a half months ago is only gaining in force. Sure there won’t be any more vehement protests like Delhi (hopefully such horrific incidents won’t happen) but the next step of the revolution has begun with a flame that has been ignited in the minds of women who have realized that when they stand up to harassment and exploitation they aren’t alone.


In every revolution the big guns or powerful figures are taken down and so have they in 2013. Asaram, Tejapal and AK Ganguly were shown their place. Sheila Dikshit was thrown out in Delhi beaten by over 25000 votes in her own constituency.





If this year’s events are anything to go by then 2014 promises much more and has the potential to change the country in more ways than previously thought possible. The mind-set change is what we need and with 65% of the Population under 35 years of age there are bright rays of hope there.


In my view 2014 will see this fight for justice continue with probably more bigwigs going to jail and finally (although this will take more than a year given how deep the mentality change is rooted) India will wake up to a morning where women are treated with respect by the whole country.








Rohit Thatte.


Original.


All Rights Reserved.

Tuesday, 26 November 2013

OF Elections, Voting, Rejection and NOTA




WHILE IT MIGHT BE EXTREMELY DEMOCRATIC AND FIND ITSELF INTO TEXTBOOKS AS A VICTORY FOR DEMOCRACY, THE “NONE OF THE ABOVE” OPTION IS NOT MUCH USEFUL IN THE REAL WORLD ELECTION SCENARIO CONSIDERING THAT THERE IS NOT A PROVISION FOR RE-ELECTION EVEN IF MAJORITY SELECT THE OPTION.




A few weeks ago the Supreme Court gave a landmark judgement ordering The Election Commission to include the right to reject all candidates as an option on the electronic voting machines.

While certainly making sense and filling a loophole in the formalities associated with democracies this option was enfeebled when it was ruled that no re-election would take place even if the majority of the voters chose the NOTA (None of the Above) option.



What with Candidates with criminal cases against them and the perception that all politicians irrespective of party lines have a general lack of interest to genuinely do good for society such an option did present a good path for people to vent their anger and frustration and anger towards the politicians.

However taking a more real world election outlook we have certain very interesting points regarding the judgement. These points become more interesting given the fact that there will be no re-election even if the majority votes have chosen “NOTA”



The first and the most obvious thought which crossed people’s minds is “How is it different from not voting?”

The truth? It isn’t much different. It is somewhat similar to the following situation. You see an advertisement of the goods on display in the supermarket in the newspaper. You decide against buying anything. NOTA is like going to the supermarket in person and telling them you don’t wish to buy anything. The end result is the same. You don’t buy anything. The shopkeeper is happy with the people that did buy something and you are err.. well disgruntled but the shopkeeper doesn’t really care given the sales he records from others.



The next point that comes to mind is the somewhat bordering on formality and would serve as interesting only on television debates. It is regarding people exercising their right to vote. Everyone should vote they say. This leads to a slightly paradoxical situation wherein people choosing NOTA have voted but not voted at all. Yes they will have indelible ink on their fingers and they would have contributed to democracy but their contribution to candidates or the victorious candidate will be negligible.



The third point that comes to mind is that of satisfaction. Choosing NOTA is absolutely certain to give satisfaction to all the voters that choose the option. However to the candidates, things like satisfaction only matter in circumstances like victory or defeat. This leads to NOTA choosers in a situation of being satisfied after rejecting all the candidates but still seeing one of the “rejected” candidates getting elected.



Still there are certain encouraging areas about the judgement.

The immediate one is that Political Parties would choose candidates with care to prevent votes from going to NOTA. Corruption, criminal cases against candidates will be seriously thought of by the parties before choosing their candidate.



The second encouraging part is that such verdicts set a platform for future verdicts in the right direction. Anna  Hazare had previously said that we need a right to recall as one of the election reforms and right now would be a good time to debate that. Yes, there are massive logistical and formal issues involved in implementing the right to recall. Even framing a law or guidelines for such a provision would be a nightmare but an open debate regarding its implementation and formation would not anachronous. However the fact that it would increase the accountability for politicians elected to office remains and systems like Performance review of the elected candidate are encouraging possibilities for future implementation.



Before I sign off it would be worthwhile to note that while haste should be avoided regarding such matters it is definitely worth a mention that undue delays which has been an integral part of the system should also be avoided.

The platform that such judgements have given the masses should be put to good use and (to use a cliché) development of democracy must be encouraged.





Rohit Thatte.

All Rights Reserved.