Of “Crony” Capitalism....
This election is very
different on many counts. The conventional wisdom seems to be thrown out of the
window. There is nothing to suggest that the old tricks in the book might work.
Since a few days the Congress
has been throwing a new “poll attack” on the BJP PM Candidate Narendra Modi.
This new attack has been adopted after the old one of “communalism” failed some
might say.
The new charge is of crony
capitalism against Narendra Modi in Gujarat for facilitating Adani, Ambani and
Ratan Tata’s huge rise in the state that benefitted the corporates much more
than the people. Another charge is that
Modi favours the corporates a lot more than state enterprises.
Is this really true? And what
does Common sense tell us about this approach? Read on.
First a small note. After
2002 there wasn’t much interest in Gujarat and the companies that did line up
at Gujarat’s doors did get in and expanded and hence we see these two
corporates associated with the state and Modi.
Secondly Ratan Tata did come
in after Modi’s Text message to him in 2009 after the West Bengal drama.
Now for what people want from
a Government. All these corporates might have managed large profits but they
have given people jobs to the region and from other regions. Voters rate jobs
and employment as pretty high this election. So as long as a good clean job is
provided they will lap it up and accept it. Consider the alternative. A
Government job. Now there is not much a government can do today without the
help of a private player or a PSU to create the amount of jobs that are
required to satiate the large number of job seekers. The instance of a
Government creating huge jobs for all the range of qualified people is rare
today if not totally non existent. Secondly Modi has turned around a Gujarat
PSU with infusion of professionalism and he was going to need external help to
create even more jobs. This help came from the private sector. Also the Central
government wasn’t that attractive at offering jobs or rather it didn’t create
any.
Secondly let us consider the
actual effect a Government undertaken work has. Consider a Government
undertaking a huge project and disbursing large amounts of money. This is not
going to work that well. History indicates that corruption will rear its ugly
head and the government ineptness at meeting deadlines will ensure that the
project is a disaster. Enter Modi. He might give the contracts to corporates
sometimes even at slightly higher rates but the job will be done impeccably.
Still not convinced? Take a
look at Bombay’s dismal roads. They are in pathetic condition every monsoon,
however the really good roads can be found at landmarks like Marine Drive. The
State might not care for a potholed alley in Kurla but when it comes to
prestigious places like South Bombay they work and ensure the BMC and State
give awesome roads. What is the secret behind this? Ensuring that contracts are
given out to proper big corporate companies like L&T and HCC etc. So where
there is capitalism that benefits we don’t mind but apply the same to the roads
of an entire state and everybody will start losing their minds.
This discrepancy might draw
reactions of sharp criticism from many but making large profits always casts
you as a thief or someone.
However if there are any
instances of the crony capitalism then they must be the Aircel-Maxis deal, the
2G Scam. The large payouts made to the suppliers of kits during the CWG Games
in 2010 indicate the crony capitalism of the UPA.
Coming back to what the
country needs it is generally true that private or corporates usually deliver
better quality of the finished products than what government undertakings do. The
finished products are what the people are going to use and hence people are
happier with better finished products.
So bottom line? What really
is crony capitalism?
Crony capitalism is actually
money paid for shoddy services.
Large sum of money paid for a
CWG Bus Stop which crumbled a month after the games. Crony Capitalism.
Large sum of money paid for a
high quality world class highway in Gujarat. Smart awarding of contracts.
Large sums of money changing
hands in a shoddy clandestine deal for spectrum. Crony Capitalism.
Large sums of money being
paid to ensure irrigation and high quality pipelines to Indian Border. Nice
move. Strengthening resources in the border towns.
So what I mean is that not
all deals involving corporates are corrupt. Of Course people might have proof
of corruption against the aforementioned corporate houses and they are free to
approach courts. Rather they should and ensure that the guilty are punished.
However to not appreciate
some genuinely good contract awarding by Indian politicians is not good. Give
credit where due.
People will always appreciate
good work done whether it is by a corporate house or by a Government
undertaking.
Rohit Thatte
No comments:
Post a Comment