Tuesday, 26 November 2013

OF Elections, Voting, Rejection and NOTA




WHILE IT MIGHT BE EXTREMELY DEMOCRATIC AND FIND ITSELF INTO TEXTBOOKS AS A VICTORY FOR DEMOCRACY, THE “NONE OF THE ABOVE” OPTION IS NOT MUCH USEFUL IN THE REAL WORLD ELECTION SCENARIO CONSIDERING THAT THERE IS NOT A PROVISION FOR RE-ELECTION EVEN IF MAJORITY SELECT THE OPTION.




A few weeks ago the Supreme Court gave a landmark judgement ordering The Election Commission to include the right to reject all candidates as an option on the electronic voting machines.

While certainly making sense and filling a loophole in the formalities associated with democracies this option was enfeebled when it was ruled that no re-election would take place even if the majority of the voters chose the NOTA (None of the Above) option.



What with Candidates with criminal cases against them and the perception that all politicians irrespective of party lines have a general lack of interest to genuinely do good for society such an option did present a good path for people to vent their anger and frustration and anger towards the politicians.

However taking a more real world election outlook we have certain very interesting points regarding the judgement. These points become more interesting given the fact that there will be no re-election even if the majority votes have chosen “NOTA”



The first and the most obvious thought which crossed people’s minds is “How is it different from not voting?”

The truth? It isn’t much different. It is somewhat similar to the following situation. You see an advertisement of the goods on display in the supermarket in the newspaper. You decide against buying anything. NOTA is like going to the supermarket in person and telling them you don’t wish to buy anything. The end result is the same. You don’t buy anything. The shopkeeper is happy with the people that did buy something and you are err.. well disgruntled but the shopkeeper doesn’t really care given the sales he records from others.



The next point that comes to mind is the somewhat bordering on formality and would serve as interesting only on television debates. It is regarding people exercising their right to vote. Everyone should vote they say. This leads to a slightly paradoxical situation wherein people choosing NOTA have voted but not voted at all. Yes they will have indelible ink on their fingers and they would have contributed to democracy but their contribution to candidates or the victorious candidate will be negligible.



The third point that comes to mind is that of satisfaction. Choosing NOTA is absolutely certain to give satisfaction to all the voters that choose the option. However to the candidates, things like satisfaction only matter in circumstances like victory or defeat. This leads to NOTA choosers in a situation of being satisfied after rejecting all the candidates but still seeing one of the “rejected” candidates getting elected.



Still there are certain encouraging areas about the judgement.

The immediate one is that Political Parties would choose candidates with care to prevent votes from going to NOTA. Corruption, criminal cases against candidates will be seriously thought of by the parties before choosing their candidate.



The second encouraging part is that such verdicts set a platform for future verdicts in the right direction. Anna  Hazare had previously said that we need a right to recall as one of the election reforms and right now would be a good time to debate that. Yes, there are massive logistical and formal issues involved in implementing the right to recall. Even framing a law or guidelines for such a provision would be a nightmare but an open debate regarding its implementation and formation would not anachronous. However the fact that it would increase the accountability for politicians elected to office remains and systems like Performance review of the elected candidate are encouraging possibilities for future implementation.



Before I sign off it would be worthwhile to note that while haste should be avoided regarding such matters it is definitely worth a mention that undue delays which has been an integral part of the system should also be avoided.

The platform that such judgements have given the masses should be put to good use and (to use a cliché) development of democracy must be encouraged.





Rohit Thatte.

All Rights Reserved.


No comments:

Post a Comment